View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0000313FSSCPgameplaypublic2005-07-22 07:37
ReporterThe Grim Reaper Assigned ToWMCoolmon  
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityalways
Status resolvedResolutionfixed 
Summary0000313: Pegasus Weapon and Tech profile mismatch
DescriptionIn ship selection Pegasus' tech profile reads two gun mounts and one missile bank, however, in the weapons loadout screen the Pegasus has one gun mount and two missile banks.

If it's of any importance, I first noticed this in the "Endgame" mission.
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

kasperl

2005-02-03 15:11

developer   ~0001628

Cam someone verify wheter this happens without the MediaVP?

WMCoolmon

2005-02-05 10:45

developer   ~0001631

It's not the mediaVPs, it happens with other Volition models too. Some of them just have the wrong techroom description data, probably because the models were changed due to balance issues and the description text was never corrected.

I added some code to read the info directly from the file if A) the model is loaded (Meaning either a needed icon for the ship isn't present or -ship_choice_3d was used) and B) no description text is found.

Fixing this would mean to override the descriptions with the actual data from the model. It'd correct problems like this, where table entries weren't updated to reflect the actual model's characteristics, but would technically be breaking backwards compatibility. (With the new loadout lines, it might be a good idea to override if the model's present and the information can be gleaned from it, or else any errors will become glaringly obvious.)

kasperl

2005-03-12 19:56

developer   ~0001748

Does anyone have any opinions on this? It seems like something perhaps worth a commandline, or debate in the forums.

phreak

2005-03-12 22:38

developer   ~0001788

Probably an oversight on V's part. I doubt anyone would notice someone changing the description for something so minor

administrator

2005-03-13 19:54

administrator   ~0001842

if we can't fix this , resolve it with can't fix.

WMCoolmon

2005-03-15 05:28

developer   ~0001958

Well, there are ways we could take care of it
1) Update the tables in the mediaVP. Takes the most work, but it'd fix it for Volition ships a long as people have mv_effects installed.
2) Change the code to grab the data from the ships table (From the Pbanks and Sbanks definitions rather than the tech description line). Problem is, this would require either hacking in ship names (Not gonna happen) or overriding all ships with the proper values. Not a bad thing in and of itself, unless a mod wants "Four" instead of "4" or something.
3) Change the code to grab the values from the model files. For Volition ships, this would only apply when someone was using ship_choice_3d.
4) Not fix it and let people deal with it.

Goober5000

2005-03-15 05:35

administrator   ~0001960

These are all messy possibilities. I vote for (4), with (1) as an option if anyone feels like doing it.

This is user error and thus only a mediaVP issue, at the very most.

kasperl

2005-04-04 17:13

developer   ~0002096

WMC: Are you going to MVP this or should I close it?

WMCoolmon

2005-04-06 08:36

developer   ~0002110

Remind me when we start talking about post 3.6.6 releases.

Goober5000

2005-05-25 02:54

administrator   ~0002492

Reminder sent to WMCoolmon

Reminder sent. Either change the MVP tables or close it, your choice. :)

Goober5000

2005-07-22 04:37

administrator   ~0002844

Reminder sent to WMCoolmon

We need to close this bug somehow. What's your decision? :p

WMCoolmon

2005-07-22 07:37

developer   ~0002858

Fixed.

Also, the Pegasus has 2 gun mounts and 2 missile banks. Mount != bank.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2005-02-02 11:34 The Grim Reaper New Issue
2005-02-03 15:11 kasperl Note Added: 0001628
2005-02-05 10:45 WMCoolmon Note Added: 0001631
2005-03-12 19:56 kasperl Note Added: 0001748
2005-03-12 22:38 phreak Note Added: 0001788
2005-03-13 19:54 administrator Note Added: 0001842
2005-03-13 19:54 administrator Assigned To => WMCoolmon
2005-03-13 19:54 administrator Status new => feedback
2005-03-15 05:28 WMCoolmon Note Added: 0001958
2005-03-15 05:35 Goober5000 Note Added: 0001960
2005-04-04 17:13 kasperl Note Added: 0002096
2005-04-06 08:36 WMCoolmon Note Added: 0002110
2005-05-25 02:54 Goober5000 Note Added: 0002492
2005-07-22 04:37 Goober5000 Note Added: 0002844
2005-07-22 07:37 WMCoolmon Status feedback => resolved
2005-07-22 07:37 WMCoolmon Resolution open => fixed
2005-07-22 07:37 WMCoolmon Note Added: 0002858